So, you’re down the pub and Terry/Terri tells you he/she’s just had a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value from his/her old Defined Benefit pension scheme and he/she’s transferred it into his/her Self-Invested Personal Pension and the world is an amazing place. Whose round is it? (Let’s agree it is Terry/Terri’s.) Alright, he/she probably wouldn’t put it quite like that.
He/she might say they’ve paid their pension pot from their XYZ company to another pension pot and now he/she’s got loads of money in his/her pension. They can now take some as a lump sum or passing some on to the kids will be so much easier.
You and Terry/Terri worked in similar industries for a similar period of time and you’re of a similar ages. You’re tempted to find out how much you’ve got in your pension. But what is a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value? Will you get as much?
Cash Equivalent Transfer Value? What are we talking about?
A Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV) is the value of your benefits in your Defined Benefit pension scheme (final salary scheme or possibly a career average scheme) which the scheme will offer to you to take somewhere else. If you took that value you would no longer have the original Defined Benefit pension and instead you would now have the money in a new pension pot. The one main drawback is that you have to transfer it to another pension arrangement.
Who decides how much my pension is worth?
This is determined by the scheme trustees and is based on a number of elements, including:
- The size of the pension you have
- The age it would be payable from (your Normal Retirement Age), which is likely to be somewhere between 60 and your state pension age.
- The amount of your pension that would be payable to your spouse/partner on your death
- The rate(s) by which your pension will increase when it’s paid (or while you’re not receiving a pension from that scheme for example if you’re younger than the scheme’s retirement age)
- The amount of money the scheme has. The scheme may reduce transfer values from time to time
- Whether the employer is supporting the scheme by allowing higher transfer values
- Economic factors to do with the interest rates and the way schemes value the benefit promises in the scheme
- The way a scheme invests its money (the split between equities, gilts, bonds etc.)
- The method of calculation the trustees decide to use
All of these factors will differ from scheme to scheme and so comparing one to the other is very difficult. There are many moving parts.
Will the value change over time?
Yes it will. In the short-term mainly due to the economic factors which underpin how the scheme values your benefit, and in the medium to long-term due to changes in the way the scheme investment the money and how the money the scheme has compares to the value of the liabilities, i.e. if a funding deficit reduces or emerges. I talk about some of that a bit more here: https://racingthetide.wordpress.com/2017/04/10/so-youve-got-a-defined-benefit-pension/
While you don’t have a pension pot with your name on it like in a defined contribution scheme the scheme has to work out the value of your individual benefit promise amongst all the others held for all the other members.
Reducing the value of MY pension – how do they get away with that?
One of the key facts of a defined benefit pension scheme, which is related to the point that you don’t have a personalised pot, means that all of the members of the scheme have a share of the funds that are there. The scheme is obligated to treat everyone fairly. Say, for example, the scheme doesn’t have enough money now to meet the total value of its promises (a common state of affairs) but if you transfer out they give you the full value of your benefit: the resultant funding of the scheme would be worse after you’ve left (having taken the full value of your benefits from an underfunded scheme), which would leave the remaining members in a worse position. That wouldn’t be fair so the legislation allows the transfer value to be reduced, but only if a scheme doesn’t have enough money now to meet the total value of its promises.
Sometimes schemes that could reduce transfer values decide not to. This may be because the employer is going to make good the difference between the reduced value and the full value, or it could be because the scheme is close to being fully funded or expects to get to full funding in the near future.
If the scheme is reducing transfer values they have to tell you when they issue the quotation to you.
How do I get a transfer value?
You have a legal right to receive one free transfer valuation a year and this will be guaranteed for 3 months to give you time to decide whether to accept it. If your full transfer value is more than £30,000 (not necessarily the reduced one) then you are required to obtain Independent Financial Advice and prove this to the trustees before you can transfer the money. If you ask, some schemes may give you another quotation for free or charge. Some schemes might even give you one without you asking for it!
When can’t I get one?
If you’re an active member of a scheme you will have to leave the scheme before you can transfer out. But you may be able to get a transfer value without leaving. If you’re a pensioner you cannot transfer out – for this reason many schemes when its members are approaching retirement will offer a last chance transfer value or a last chance reminder.
Divorce?
The exceptions to the rules above are if you’re getting divorced and you’re required to provide a value of your pension for the court. In essence this is the same calculation but a court may subsequently direct that the pension benefits are divided, for example by a pension sharing order (i.e. some of your pension will now be payable to your ex-spouse). May have to save a further description of this to another day.
Why do people keep talking about them these days?
This is primarily a combination of two things. Firstly, the government introduced rules from April 2015 which only had an impact on defined contribution schemes but it meant that there was more flexibility in the system to allow people with defined contribution funds to access them flexibly. Secondly, the size of transfer values from defined benefit schemes, due to the economic factors, are currently very large and this can appear very attractive to those that want to increase their ability to use the new flexibilities.
Is there a way of knowing if the transfer value is worth taking?
This is the $1m dollar question. Based on the facts today, including your personal circumstances an Independent Financial Adviser will be able to help you with that. But this is difficult and is based on many factors (the list below is a taster of the things to think about):
- The size of the transfer value should be compared to the benefits you’re losing. Sometimes transfers can appear extremely generous, and they will be large. But at a glance it isn’t easy to understand what you should be comparing this to: the size of your pension when you left the scheme, the size of your pension as it would be today (allowing for inflation/scheme guarantees), the size you might expect at your retirement date or whether the transfer value would enable you to replicate a pension broadly equivalent in size to the one you’re giving up.
- There is a risk exchange here too. The risk of your fund decreasing i.e. your retirement reducing, falls to you if you transfer out. Of course there is an upside possibility too – and of course you may do well.
So, in a nutshell that’s what CETVs are. They are not all equal. The pension you have has a value and this can be in two senses of the word. It has a value to you as an income stream in later life that is fairly secure. It is far more likely it will be there when you retire than it won’t. But it also has a monetary value if taken as a one-off cash hit (from the scheme’s perspective). That value, for many could easily be hundreds of thousands of pounds, or even millions.
Taking the value, if you’re over 55 (the earliest age at which pension assets can be accessed), could make you a millionaire overnight. But of course you already are a millionaire but the pension assets are just held in a different way to be taken at a different time. It also isn’t like having a million in the bank (you’ve already paid income tax on that) as you’ll pay tax as the pension is paid out (after the first 25% tax-free slug).
Pensions (especially defined benefit pensions) are an incredibly valuable asset and could be equivalent to, or even exceed, the value of your house.