The Letter of Resignation

I was looking for some old documents on my hard drive last week and found a letter from December 2013 called “Letter of Resignation”. I half scoffed as I remembered it. I recalled writing it and think about it from time to time but it wasn’t something that I’d read probably since I wrote it. I opened it.

I remember writing it on a train up from the south coast, where I lived, to London. I can recall the tears in my eyes as I banged the keyboard. This isn’t a one line – “I’m off” it was a cry for help that no one would read. I needed to get it out. I was effectively screaming into a laptop.

It was never written to be sent. I wasn’t going to resign. I couldn’t. I was the income provider for a home with two kids (three at this time). There wasn’t any way on earth I could just walk away.

The letter is at times laughably petty and self-pitying. It was a stream of consciousness of someone trapped in a world they couldn’t relate to. A job that they felt they had to compromise themselves to do properly.

Dave in 2013 is a different person than Dave now. It has scared me looking back. I remember the feelings I describe. They were so frequent the muscle memory is there. Crying on the train. Feeling sick in the pit of my stomach. Resenting the work that I was not taking any satisfaction from but that provided a secure income and a home. They’ve stayed with me since I re-read it last week like the hangover of a dream that’s disturbed you. They’re not real but they were real. They were in me and, in a way, they’re still in me. It is me.

The penultimate paragraph was the one that hit me “The problem is I have no idea what to do but I know if I carry on coming in to this office…I am probably going to kill myself.” I almost certainly probably wasn’t. But I didn’t use those words lightly. I was at the lowest point ever. I would expect (I haven’t asked) that my colleagues would have no idea what I was going through. If they were to read this now they may be surprised that for a good few years these feelings were my life.

I learnt to flick the switch. Telephone rings “smile” – in a meeting “smile and chat”. Sometimes after a drink the mask might slip but nearly all the time the mask remained firmly in place until someone wasn’t looking. We’ve all worn that mask I am sure. Behind the scenes life is too much. Life is too hard but the show must go on.

Looking back I should have stopped. Said to my boss I need a break. But I was too scared of the repercussions. Loss of face, respect or opportunity. That’s what I felt. No, I must carry on. If I give a glimpse that I can’t handle it I’ll lose it. I didn’t see others struggling so I felt I must carry on and push on. They can do it.

Looking back, I don’t really know what it was.

I am pretty sure I am not the only one that feels like this or has felt this or will feel like this.

Seven years on life is better in many ways. Still have the odd wobble but I have learned to cope better. Medicine helped for a while. Getting the balance right is important. The initial covid pandemic was a tough time. The first six months of home learning and working on my own in a house I was renting as life was in a period of massive change. The guilt of not doing my job well and not helping my kids properly nearly sent me on that spiral again. But friends in and out of work, and of course my amazing girlfriend, helped.  (They may not have known they were helping but laughter is something I cling on to like a life raft.)

This isn’t meant to be a moral tale or a key to helping but by writing this I want to assure those that are suffering know they’re not alone. Life is hard. Sometimes things aren’t the way we want and our reactions are not how we would want them to be. We make mistakes and make a mess. But things do change. Things can improve.

I feel bad for Dave back then. It makes me sad now to think about how sad he was and for how long. But he isn’t sad now.

Bass

This is my bass. There are many like them but this one is mine.

This bass is special. It’s a link back to my dad. He bought it for me 20+ years ago. Mainly because my band mate Paul was sick of me playing his. I had, for a short while, had a bass made of solid ash. That was a shoulder crushing beast! But this was the real deal.

I’m no Jaco Pastorious. https://youtu.be/nsZ_1mPOuyk I’m a pretty solid bass player. Give me enough time and I’ll give you a rough approximation of what you like (just no Weather Report and not too much slapping and popping).

However the joy playing this hunk of wood is indescribable. It’s a link back to the best of times playing with some proper talented people. Paul, Smudge and my rhythm section mate Jay in Book Harrison the highlight. There haven’t been many other forays into performance since. Playing with Simon and Dick in some dingy rehearsal room around Waterloo in London were much needed escape during some tough times. Life is busy and maybe I’ll never play properly again.

Now it’s generally me on the sofa fumbling through a few old songs and trying to learn something new. 46&2 has become a bit of an obsession…

I nearly sold this thing when times were tough. Now I hope never to part with it. Losing it would have been a disaster. It’s beautiful, objectively as an item. But it also represents past love of father to son. Also of camaraderie and connections many people never experience. It’s become my most treasured possession.

Thanks Dad! Thank you band mates for making it more than a hunk of wood.

My bass, without me, is useless. Without my bass, I am useless.

Grief, denial and doppelgängers

Grief does crazy things to our brains. Certainly my brain.

This is a brief description of the craziness that goes on in my head. Hope it helps someone who may have the same or similar accept it and learn to cope with it. You’re not alone.

My father died quite a while ago now. Just over 19 years. It was a shock. I was living away and when told he was having a heart attack rushed home but too late to say goodbye. I still recall the strong feeling of disbelief. I don’t think that will ever leave. However, it is that disbelief that fuels my crazy thoughts. I have only recently told someone that for a few years afterwards I didn’t really believe he was dead. This has (in hindsight) confused my grieving process. I knew it wasn’t true but I also simultaneously believed that my father had faked his own death and had moved away. This theory gradually faded overtime but at times, weak times, when the pain was too much, I’d let that thought back in. Give it some room to grow in my head and then the situation didn’t feel so bad. He’s alive and happy somewhere. That thought would fade and I’d accept the truth and carry on. The thought doesn’t really come into my mind much these days except when I see a my dad’s doppelgänger. This must be a thing many people experience.

My dad was tall, bald with a sort of striking hang dog face. So as I project forward what he would look like now I have, quite a few times, bumped into my “dad” who faked it. The last time was this last week in Gatwick. I’d forgotten my toothbrush popped into boots and in the queue to pay, there was “dad”. Looking dapper in a red jumper and red Chelsea boots (strong look). He looked healthy and happy. Looked like he was off on holiday, somewhere hot. My dad loved sun-bathing.

It’s a blind siding delusion. Half of the fun is to wallow in but the downside is he sort of dies again as I realise he isn’t really there buying some bits and bobs from boots. The random dad-like person must also be slightly freaked out as I stare at them as they go about their business.

I know for a fact this will happen again and I know one part of me will enjoy it but the other will hurt all over again.

Grief! I’ll never understand it.

WASPI and Dunning Kruger

I know more than the average person does about pensions. I am comfortable saying that as a fact. I don’t know everything and many people know more than me. That’s life and I can live with it.

However, I certainly know less than the average on about a million other topics.

I have previously written about the Dunning-Kruger effect but the rise (and fall and rise) of twitter is the perfect place to see people falling under its spell time and time again.
The Dunning-Kruger effect is something that we have all experienced, perhaps without knowing it. It helps describe that moment when you believe you understand something – but in reality you are so ignorant of it you barely understand your own ignorance.

As David Dunning (co-author of the effect with Justin Kruger at Cornell University in 1999) has explained “…incompetent people do not recognise – scratch that, cannot recognise – just how incompetent they are.”
He continues: “What’s curious is that, in many cases, incompetence does not leave people disorientated, perplexed or cautious. Instead, the incompetent are often blessed with an inappropriate confidence, buoyed by something that feels to them like knowledge.”
Their study shows that while proficient individuals will underrate their ability, the majority increasingly overrate their aptitude. One should also note that everyone thinks they’re above average and something they’re not. What feeds this, it isn’t simply “the more incompetent you are the more knowledgeable you think you are”. It is fed by ego and people’s ability to recognise ignorance in others, but failure to recognise one’s own.

This is also fed by confirmation bias: the ability to remember the things we get right and ignore the things we get wrong.

The words used to describe this mental process aren’t supposed to belittle. It is easy to be arrogant and condescending and think “we’re surrounded by fools!” but it is important to recognise that on ANY given topic we are ALL on the curve of unrecognised ignorance.
You may feel there is a particular topic about which you are an expert. However, to understand what the majority experience you need to think of other areas where in fact the extent of your knowledge barely stretches to the extent of your ignorance.

One way to understand the impact of this is think of an area you excel at, consider how much the average person knows about that area. They know very little and it is clear they know very little about how little they know. Now, consider you are as ignorant about every other area of knowledge that you are not expert.
If you can achieve that exercise then you will now have a large dose of humility about what you do and do not know. If you’re embarking on a mission to learn about pensions learn from Dunning and Kruger. Learn that thinking critically using logic and empiricism and presume you don’t know everything. If you do that we’re more likely to be correct and make better choices.
Where WASPI comes in is my observation, largely as a bystander, at the level of debate on twitter around their “ask” and the facts they believe as facts surrounding state and private pensions. As I have outlined I am not belittling and I am not being patronising when I say that pensions are complicated. Horrendously so. State pension and private pensions interact at many levels, cross over and there are swathes of pensions legislation.

As a technical expert on pensions almost all my answers start with some teeth sucking. “It depends…” will generally be the first two words out of my mouth. For a lay-person to wade into this debate they have my best wishes and pity as someone out there will know the answer and have evidence to support it.

WASPI supporters believe they have been dealt a historic injustice and the only solution is a position to financially compensate them for “lost” state pension.

I personally believe the answer to the grievance is, potentially, a review around some targeted means-tested solution which may alleviate some that are suffering but shouldn’t be a sweeping solution for all.
However, the debate currently being waged is poor. It is full of half-truths, misunderstandings and confusion. There also seems to be a WASPI angle to every news story. This false equivalence does much to discredit their position.

This short piece isn’t intended to be a myth buster (others have done that) but is really a plea. For many years’ experts in pensions, economics and politics have engaged WASPI supporters to correct misunderstandings, lies and untruths. However, these experts are labelled “trolls”, shills and detractors (and sometimes worse). I believe more could have been achieved for those in need if the WASPI hierarchy and supporters acted in a way that when corrected they correct their beliefs. We should all do that. Believe something based on evidence not based on what we want it to be. If I believe something for which there is no evidence, I’ll stop believing it.
I have learnt a great deal from twitter by engaging with and listening (or just paying attention) to those that know more than me. It’s how a rational mind should work. I would urge WASPI supporters to do the same. Allow your beliefs to be challenged, you might be wrong. Also play the argument and not the person. If someone thinks you’re being foolish (and tells you) don’t think they’re summing up your whole character, they’re not. As we’ve learnt we’re all idiots on something at some time but it doesn’t sum you up completely.
My hope is that if one WASPI person reads this and recognises the errors they’re making and while they can argue for a solution I would love the false equivalence with every pensions story and accusations against those experts with a different view to end.

Victory for what is right

The Walker v Innospec case reached its conclusion on 12 July 2017 with a unanimous Supreme Court ruling that meant that an exemption from the Equality Act 2010 (and its related EU Directive) could not be relied upon when discriminating against homosexual couples.

It almost feels crazy to even have to explain this but from 2005 and the passing of the Civil Partnerships Act and then the upgrade legislation in 2013 which introduced “same-sex” marriage equality wasn’t quite equal. Pension schemes only had to provide as a minimum spouse’s pension from rights accrued since 2005 and contracted out rights from after April 1988. So not equal at all.

The tenacious Mr Walker, seeking assurances from his ex-employer’s pension scheme, took the case through an employment tribunal, high court, appeal court and ultimately the Supreme Court where they found in his favour.

The big question now is what does this mean for same-sex married couples. It would appear that the arguments justifying the continuation of the different treatment have all been blown out of the water so that ALL pension schemes that had previously restricted rights for same-sex married couples will now have to provide benefits on the same basis as opposite sex couples. This would also mean a recalculation of benefits in payment.

However, there is an ancillary issue regarding our old friend GMP. People may not appreciate that should a woman die and she has pre-88 GMP there is not attaching widower’s pension. This is a hangover from the way GMP was established but it is understood that the Government believes that if this ruling were to occur then this anomaly would also have to be corrected. We’ll have to await comment from the Government before proceeding on this point. Clearly this will result in some work.

Now many people have commented that funding costs will rise, and they might, but this will be by trivial amounts in the big scheme of things. It is common to have an allowance for married people in the valuation and so this ruling would increase the chances of paying a full spouse’s pension, but only on the margins. However, if we factor in the costs of the GMP equalisation an upper estimate would take this to a cost of £3bn, of which £2.6bn is in the public sector. These may appear like big numbers but in the context of the billions of pounds wrapped up in pensions this really is nothing more than a rounding to correct something that was clearly wrong.

It’s a wonderful result and one which meant I had to wipe a small tear from my eye. It is rare in pensions to have such an open and shut case but a shame it had to go all the way to the top to be resolved.

Terry/Terri got a CETV

So, you’re down the pub and Terry/Terri tells you he/she’s just had a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value from his/her old Defined Benefit pension scheme and he/she’s transferred it into his/her Self-Invested Personal Pension and the world is an amazing place. Whose round is it? (Let’s agree it is Terry/Terri’s.) Alright, he/she probably wouldn’t put it quite like that.

He/she might say they’ve paid their pension pot from their XYZ company  to another pension pot and now he/she’s got loads of money in his/her pension. They can now take some as a lump sum or passing some on to the kids will be so much easier.

You and Terry/Terri worked in similar industries for a similar period of time and you’re of a similar ages. You’re tempted to find out how much you’ve got in your pension. But what is a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value? Will you get as much?

Cash Equivalent Transfer Value? What are we talking about?

A Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV) is the value of your benefits in your Defined Benefit pension scheme (final salary scheme or possibly a career average scheme) which the scheme will offer to you to take somewhere else. If you took that value you would no longer have the original Defined Benefit pension and instead you would now have the money in a new pension pot. The one main drawback is that you have to transfer it to another pension arrangement.

Who decides how much my pension is worth?

This is determined by the scheme trustees and is based on a number of elements, including:

  • The size of the pension you have
  • The age it would be payable from (your Normal Retirement Age), which is likely to be somewhere between 60 and your state pension age.
  • The amount of your pension that would be payable to your spouse/partner on your death
  • The rate(s) by which your pension will increase when it’s paid (or while you’re not receiving a pension from that scheme for example if you’re younger than the scheme’s retirement age)
  • The amount of money the scheme has. The scheme may reduce transfer values from time to time
  • Whether the employer is supporting the scheme by allowing higher transfer values
  • Economic factors to do with the interest rates and the way schemes value the benefit promises in the scheme
  • The way a scheme invests its money (the split between equities, gilts, bonds etc.)
  • The method of calculation the trustees decide to use

All of these factors will differ from scheme to scheme and so comparing one to the other is very difficult. There are many moving parts.

Will the value change over time?

Yes it will. In the short-term mainly due to the economic factors which underpin how the scheme values your benefit, and in the medium to long-term due to changes in the way the scheme investment the money and how the money the scheme has compares to the value of the liabilities, i.e. if a funding deficit reduces or emerges. I talk about some of that a bit more here: https://racingthetide.wordpress.com/2017/04/10/so-youve-got-a-defined-benefit-pension/

While you don’t have a pension pot with your name on it like in a defined contribution scheme the scheme has to work out the value of your individual benefit promise amongst all the others held for all the other members.

Reducing the value of MY pension – how do they get away with that?

One of the key facts of a defined benefit pension scheme, which is related to the point that you don’t have a personalised pot, means that all of the members of the scheme have a share of the funds that are there. The scheme is obligated to treat everyone fairly. Say, for example, the scheme doesn’t have enough money now to meet the total value of its promises (a common state of affairs) but if you transfer out they give you the full value of your benefit: the resultant funding of the scheme would be worse after you’ve left (having taken the full value of your benefits from an underfunded scheme), which would leave the remaining members in a worse position. That wouldn’t be fair so the legislation allows the transfer value to be reduced, but only if a scheme doesn’t have enough money now to meet the total value of its promises.

Sometimes schemes that could reduce transfer values decide not to. This may be because the employer is going to make good the difference between the reduced value and the full value, or it could be because the scheme is close to being fully funded or expects to get to full funding in the near future.

If the scheme is reducing transfer values they have to tell you when they issue the quotation to you.

How do I get a transfer value?

You have a legal right to receive one free transfer valuation a year and this will be guaranteed for 3 months to give you time to decide whether to accept it. If your full transfer value is more than £30,000 (not necessarily the reduced one) then you are required to obtain Independent Financial Advice and prove this to the trustees before you can transfer the money. If you ask, some schemes may give you another quotation for free or charge. Some schemes might even give you one without you asking for it!

When can’t I get one?

If you’re an active member of a scheme you will have to leave the scheme before you can transfer out. But you may be able to get a transfer value without leaving. If you’re a pensioner you cannot transfer out – for this reason many schemes when its members are approaching retirement will offer a last chance transfer value or a last chance reminder.

Divorce?

The exceptions to the rules above are if you’re getting divorced and you’re required to provide a value of your pension for the court. In essence this is the same calculation but a court may subsequently direct that the pension benefits are divided, for example by a pension sharing order (i.e. some of your pension will now be payable to your ex-spouse). May have to save a further description of this to another day.

Why do people keep talking about them these days?

This is primarily a combination of two things. Firstly, the government introduced rules from April 2015 which only had an impact on defined contribution schemes but it meant that there was more flexibility in the system to allow people with defined contribution funds to access them flexibly. Secondly, the size of transfer values from defined benefit schemes, due to the economic factors, are currently very large and this can appear very attractive to those that want to increase their ability to use the new flexibilities.

Is there a way of knowing if the transfer value is worth taking? 

This is the $1m dollar question. Based on the facts today, including your personal circumstances an Independent Financial Adviser will be able to help you with that. But this is difficult and is based on many factors (the list below is a taster of the things to think about):

  • The size of the transfer value should be compared to the benefits you’re losing. Sometimes transfers can appear extremely generous, and they will be large. But at a glance it isn’t easy to understand what you should be comparing this to: the size of your pension when you left the scheme, the size of your pension as it would be today (allowing for inflation/scheme guarantees), the size you might expect at your retirement date or whether the transfer value would enable you to replicate a pension broadly equivalent in size to the one you’re giving up.
  • There is a risk exchange here too. The risk of your fund decreasing i.e. your retirement reducing, falls to you if you transfer out. Of course there is an upside possibility too – and of course you may do well.

So, in a nutshell that’s what CETVs are. They are not all equal. The pension you have has a value and this can be in two senses of the word. It has a value to you as an income stream in later life that is fairly secure. It is far more likely it will be there when you retire than it won’t. But it also has a monetary value if taken as a one-off cash hit (from the scheme’s perspective). That value, for many could easily be hundreds of thousands of pounds, or even millions.

Taking the value, if you’re over 55 (the earliest age at which pension assets can be accessed), could make you a millionaire overnight. But of course you already are a millionaire but the pension assets are just held in a different way to be taken at a different time. It also isn’t like having a million in the bank (you’ve already paid income tax on that) as you’ll pay tax as the pension is paid out (after the first 25% tax-free slug).

Pensions (especially defined benefit pensions) are an incredibly valuable asset and could be equivalent to, or even exceed, the value of your house.

So you’ve got a Defined Benefit Pension?

First things first. Congratulations. You have worked (or still do) for an employer who decided to offer you the crème de la crème of retirement provision, a Defined Benefit pension.

These types of schemes come in many different shapes and sizes but by and large they will try and offer you a pension at retirement based upon the amount of time you were a member of the scheme and the amount of money you earned. If you’ve been in one of these schemes since the mid-to-late 80s there will also be an element of inflation linking both when you cease to be a member and also after your retirement.

I won’t get into the details here of what those different pension types are but suffice to say the employer bears the responsibility to pay money into the scheme to ensure that when you retire, there is enough money there to pay your pension until you die

This is the bottom line of why Defined Benefit pensions are so great. The risk and responsibility is on the employer to put the money aside for you, irrespective of how long you live. It is also one of the reasons that these schemes are so expensive. Predicting how long you’ll live and how much money the pension scheme will need for you (and all the other members) until everyone is dead (including spouses as these pensions will commonly include an allowance for a spouse’s pension) is difficult and making such a commitment is expensive.

Isn’t my pension guaranteed?

No, not really. I suppose you could say it is in the sense that the scheme has promised to pay you a benefit based on the Scheme’s rules. However, they will only be able to pay this on an ongoing basis if there is enough money in the scheme and if the sponsor is a solvent company. If the employer fails and there isn’t enough money in the scheme then you may be destined for the Pension Protection Fund (PPF).

Why should I care?

The security of DB pensions is on everyone’s minds with the recent high profile case of BHS. However, BHS aren’t the first sponsor to fail with a pension scheme destined for the PPF and they won’t be the last. The Scheme you’re a member of could be fine but there is a chance it won’t be, and you should use the information you have been given in the form of benefits statements and Summary Funding Statements to determine your current position.

How do I know what the position is?

Every year (or sometimes every 3 years if your scheme is small) the Trustees will write to you with a Summary Funding Statement (SFS). This can be a turgid document but it’s the best thing you’ve got to understand how the scheme is getting on. It will show the scheme’s assets and the present value of its benefit promises (liabilities). For many schemes this will show they don’t have enough money right now. This is partly caused by the way the scheme values its promises which have become more expensive for many schemes over the years. However, what the SFS doesn’t show is the employer’s strength. This is important as they are standing behind the scheme and possibly pledging to pay millions of pounds in to keep the scheme in a position to pay the benefits.

What about the employer’s strength?

If the number showing the difference between the assets and liabilities on your scheme’s SFS is negative and the employer fails there will not be enough money to cover all the benefits. This means that being in a position to understand the strength of the employer is very important. However, this is difficult to assess for anyone. The Trustees have a duty to assess the ability of the employer to meet the ongoing needs of the scheme (often called the employer covenant). This assessment will determine how the Trustees set some of the assumptions when calculating the size of the liability and the structure of a plan to make the deficit smaller and even turn it into a surplus.

How can I find out the strength of an employer covenant?

This is an incredibly important question and one that is extremely difficult to answer. You would need to look at the company accounts, understand the industry and, to some extent, understand the legal structure of the company and its relationship with the scheme.

This will be beyond the abilities of most members to assess and so you should try, as best you can, to take a pragmatic view relying on publicly available information. For instance, you may want to look at the contributions the company pays and its history of paying these in relation to the size of the business. This may give some indication of the employer’s attitude to the scheme and the strain, or not, on the company. This will be shown in the company accounts which you can get online from companies house.

What does the PPF pay?

The PPF compensation that would be payable to you can be a little complicated but in general if you are older your scheme’s normal retirement age (or retired on ill health grounds or are receiving a spouse’s pension) when the employer fails you will continue to receive all of your pension, however the pension increases in payment maybe slightly lower as the PPF uses CPI with a 2.5% cap in general as opposed to RPI which schemes may use.

If you are younger than your scheme’s normal retirement age, you will receive a pension equal to 90% of the compensation cap. For a 65 year old this would be a cap of £ 38,505 (as of April 2017), so 90% = £34,654. There is also a service element if you’ve been in a scheme for more than 20 years so you may get more than this.

PPF isn’t fantastic, but it is far better than nothing.

What will happen to my scheme?

The lifespan and direction of a pension scheme can be hard to predict but in general the path will end in 2 places, but there is a third position which will hold sway for many years to come:

  1. The scheme is passed to an insurer. Essentially the Trustees/employer will approach an insurance company and ask them to take responsibility for paying the benefits. This can be expensive for the scheme as the insurer wants a lot of money to insure there are sufficient funds to pay the pensions and they want to make a profit too.
  2. The employer goes bust and there isn’t enough money for option 1 (or and option 1a which would be better benefits than the PPF provide but via an insurance company) and so it goes into the PPF – and (as described above) the PPF takes over the benefits and all the assets.
  3. However, the third way will be the case for many years to come. Basically the company continues to sponsor the scheme and it carries on. Many schemes will be working towards position number 1 but it may take some time. During that time 2 may happen.

So what? I just leave it there?

So, if you have DB scheme you have a valuable benefit which is promising to pay you a pension for the rest of your life, at least, as it may pay more to a spouse or partner.

Leaving those benefits where they are will be the best way to ensure that you have a secure income and taking that pension elsewhere is a risky endeavour as the risk will became yours and yours alone.

Some people believe they can do better elsewhere and they’d like to unlock benefits that would be contingent on them being married (when they aren’t) and living a long time (when they’re convinced they won’t). These factors are hard to quantify as the value in the scheme for those benefits may not be as large as you think and this will depend on a number of factors too varied to go into here.

If I were you I would think very carefully about what you should do with that pension and why you think you can do better elsewhere. If you’re getting twitchy I suggest getting some independent financial advice but note that this in itself can be an expensive endeavor. Advising on these things can be difficult and risky for the adviser if they get it wrong and of course your future retirement may not be as pleasant.

Tread carefully.

 

This has been written in my capacity as a Techie pensions bod and reflects my views and not the views of my employer (although it might, I haven’t asked them).

Hobbes v Locke

Locke or Hobbes?

Pension Freedoms has been around for nearly two years and yet it still feels new, and dare I say it exciting, perhaps challenging is the right buzz word

Recent figures released show that since its launch £9.2bn has been taken from pension funds through the freedoms and over the last 3 months £1.6bn has been taken out with one million payments between April and December 2016.

These are big numbers.

Is this a success for the Government’s new system? I think it has to be an undoubted yes. If the goal is that people can access their benefits flexibly without being “forced” to buy an annuity, then it is certainly mission accomplished.

I have never been one of the pension freedoms biggest fans but I can see that freedom should be generally encouraged. As John Locke might say men can “order their actions, and dispose of their possessions as they think fit”. Why shouldn’t pensions saving be like that? We are an ocean of individuals and one size doesn’t fit all. Similarly Locke may not have lost too much sleep over an increase in DB transfers as the security it gives (and other bells and whistles) may not be valued in the same way by all. We should all have the equality to do what we want.

However, the Hobbesian in me worries that we need more paternalism and security via a controlling force. I get the impression that many don’t give a hoot about those individuals that are making poor short-term decisions with long-term savings. Withdrawing sums to sit in the bank or blowing it. Was that the point of their pension? I feel strongly that the pension was earned to provide support later in life and for many (nearly millions) the cupboard is now bare.

I can’t help but think we have lurched from Hobbesian choice above to a Locke like extreme without taking a step in the middle.

The old rules had a decent level of flexibility

  • Capped drawdown – if you want some flexibility
  • Flexible drawdown (if you had enough secured income)
  • Tax-free cash and no income
  • Annuity – if you want security (but you have a choice)
  • Small lump sum – if you qualified

Imagine a different scenario where George Osborne decided to slightly relax the small lump sum rules, increase capped drawdown limits and reduce the level of secured income for flexible drawdown. We might not have the scenario where there was rush to bust out billions from pension pots/retirement savings and DB funds. Rather some element of protection and control would remain to ensure those who cannot afford to lose it retain something – but those with small sums that perhaps are less likely to be life changing can be used in a practical manner.

It would also not have been the whizz-bang announcement that created a fertile culture for certain low-lifes to propagate and scam people.

I know this isn’t rocket science but the losers in all this will, at an individual level, be obvious as they survive on a small and receding state pension. However, we are storing up a potential future problem with increase pension poverty where, if society agrees, more support may be needed for those that have deprived themselves of a more secure retirement.

So Locke or Hobbes? For me it has to be some more Hobbes. Although pension freedoms will never be undone I just hope this rush turns into more a trickle. With the decline of DB provision where DC becomes all people (like me) have got, rationally it has to but by then it might be too late.

Pensions Fiddling

The current consensus is that tax relief as we know it is an unfair dinosaur that should be done away with.

Who tells us this? In general the message is given by old men in grey suits. It is inter-generationally unfair! The Government can’t afford the level of tax relief that’s given! It does not incentivise people to save!

Unless you’re affected by the Annual Allowance, Lifetime Allowance or both the tax relief works by allowing you to pay contributions gross at the highest rate of income tax. This has been the case for (say) 50 years. I feel secure in saying the majority of people that now tell us that tax relief is broken and needs fixing have built up nice big fat pension pots enjoying full tax relief for a large part of their career.

There will be a significant cohort of middle-aged people*, who have worked in the private sector who have no DB savings. For them the matching employer contribution and the higher rate of tax relief is a major incentive to save – or make the effort to save. Losing the tax relief will be a significant loss to their long-term savings plan. Their state pension is likely to be pushing 70 and will, by then, truly be a disaster recovery provision and DC will be all they have. These people may not be the people who the Government care about when it thinks about inter-generational fairness but they should.

If the Government wants to be inter-generationally fair slash the Lifetime Allowance – correct some of that over generous tax relief given in the past if it was so unfair and reduce the Annual Allowance to stop wealthy people squirrelling more money away. I don’t necessarily want that but if the Government want to reduce the tax relief bill plus be inter-generationally fairer then this could be the easy way to do it.

The Government have conducted a massive swindle on the way we look at tax relief and the way the incentive should work. We have been shown the world from the Government’s perspective, they “lose” £35bn in tax relief a year on pensions but we already know a fair chunk of that is employer DB contributions and I haven’t heard any suggestions to reduce the corporate tax relief, they know they wouldn’t get away with that and the “DB problem” won’t be solved that way.

A radical idea I read the other day (apologies to the person as I can’t find it now) is a lifetime contribution limit. Perhaps this would be a useful way of giving a finite level of contributions that people may want to store up for when they are a higher rate tax payer. What level that should be set at I don’t know (I wrote this quickly after thinking it on a run round Regent’s Park yesterday) but it is certainly an interesting idea. I can hear financial planners scrabbling for their calculators to work out how best to use it.

Tax relief as it currently works is ok (I set aside the issue of very low earners who miss on the reliefs) for the member and the only way they will understand is by changing the way we represent it and explain to people. Switching it around and levelling down helps no-one.

 * Full disclosure I am one.

** The article I couldn’t remember was almost certainly this – http://www.adviserlounge.co.uk/2014/02/27/its-all-arse-about-face/

This article may not mirror the views of my employer (I haven’t asked them).

 

The winding down of DB world – it’s getting tricky

The death throes of the Defined Benefit pension experiment look like they will be compelling viewing (and an interesting thing to be involved in). While the number of extant DB schemes is going in one direction, how we get to one (spoiler: probably the PPF) is not obvious.

I am sure if you’re reading this you know about the BHS saga which is on running. I don’t want to try and pre-empt the conclusion of the investigation from tPR or the more important select committee inquiry which is likely to run over the summer with more evidence to be heard.

However, a sub-text is emerging which highlights two problems:
1. The Pensions regulator, has it got the teeth it needs? If yes, has it used them effectively and if not should it have them sharpened or some new angry looking dentures?

2. What are we going to do with all these DB schemes?

My intention is to try and give some thought on the DB world’s future.

Are we overreacting to BHS?

The PPF seem fairly sanguine about the arrival of the BHS Pension Scheme into the PPF. In the big scheme of things this event is what it plans for and does not seem to be overly concerned about it. It’s what it’s there for. Ultimately the PPF can take it, for the time being. If the PPF starts to struggle the compensation can be changed to keep it afloat and, while not explicitly stated, ultimately the Government would step in to top it up. But that may not be needed for a long time. So a BHS could go into the PPF every year and the world carries on turning just fine.
So employers carry on paying what they can keeping that balance between deficit recovery and future investment in their business.

How long can employers last?

However, employers may have tried to stash some capital to ride out this stagnant period but how much do they have left? While technically not a recession this strained period for nigh on 8 years is longer than anyone expected. Do we owe it to employers lumbered with these DB schemes to help them out of the drain on their assets and relieve them of their obligations?

The PPF is like a black hole

PPF lurks at the centre of our DB galaxy like a black hole slowly sucking schemes too weak to resist in. So should we accelerate this and push some schemes in to the PPF earlier? This realises the issue more quickly and would be bad news for members, who would have their benefits restricted earlier, but ultimately reduces the extent of “PPF drift” where the cost to the PPF increases over time. So we could establish a ratio by which the schemes least likely to ever make it to control their own destinies are tumbled into the PPF in a controlled manner rather than in panic. I have dubbed this PPF Drag. This would involve re-writing PPF entry rules and some very difficult decisions.

Should we just play on while the chaos goes on around us?

Do we carry on in the hope that interest rate rises come soon? Will we look back on this period in the same way people look back on the high interest rates in the 80s and be grateful we didn’t blink?

That is a call for an economist (and probably more than one) but we could delay doing the really scary stuff (PPF drag and the proposals to change funding rules) and help schemes to reduce the liabilities they have. The only way to do this would be to reduce benefits or member protections against “bad outcomes”. However, we should consider whether the Government could:

• Say that all benefits will increase by CPI, which would save a few billion.
• Relax the rules (and complications) around triviality exercises from DB schemes. For instance make the £30,000 limit higher, scheme specific and remove the 12 month window for any trivial commutations to increase the flexibility for individuals
• Review the advice requirement for transfer values. Reduce the limit for advice and increase the visibility of statutory warnings
• Allow pensioners to transfer-out (if it’s good enough for annuities why not DB)
• Allow DB schemes to pay higher cash sums (taxed over 25%)
• Consider allowing schemes to cap benefits or increases earned – this goes against the grain of the protection of subsisting rights but past generosity may have to be reviewed

What should we do?
These, perhaps unpalatable, things need to be considered to help solve the problem of DB. The solutions will result in lower benefits for many people but it would seem that employers are reaching breaking point with these never ending costs caused by DB promises and so we need to do something drastic. I say that employers are near breaking in the knowledge of dividends paid in the past etc. but the fact is we are fast approaching a crisis (if not are already in one).

My preference is to ease the rules on DB benefits to allow schemes to re-package the benefits they offer their members and provide more flexibility as this will shave some of that cost off. DB members have been made promises that have proved vastly more valuable than was understood at the time. They have effectively won the pensions lottery. In the context of the IFS studies showing that many pensioners have more disposable income that many workers is it unreasonable to ask them to shoulder some share of the burden?

However, even with the tinkering I would like to see the planning begin for a controlled exit of the DB system in a way that preserves employers and members benefits as far as possible.